The Ultimate Guide to Finding the Perfect Peanut Butter and Jelly Combination

There’s something nostalgic about a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It’s a classic comfort food that brings back memories of childhood. But as an adult, you might find yourself wondering if there’s a way to elevate this simple sandwich to new culinary heights. The answer lies in finding the perfect combination of peanut butter and jelly. But with so many brands and flavors on the market, where do you start? This ultimate guide will help you navigate the world of peanut butter and jelly to find your perfect match.

Understanding Your Peanut Butter Options

When it comes to peanut butter, there are two main types to consider: creamy and crunchy. Creamy peanut butter is smooth and easy to spread, while crunchy peanut butter contains bits of peanuts for added texture. Some popular brands include Jif, Skippy, and Peter Pan. But don’t overlook smaller, artisanal brands that may offer unique flavors and textures.


Jif is known for its creamy texture and rich, peanutty flavor. It’s a great all-around choice that pairs well with most types of jelly.


Skippy is slightly sweeter than Jif, with a smooth, velvety texture. It’s a good choice if you prefer a sweeter peanut butter or if you’re pairing it with a tart jelly.

Peter Pan

Peter Pan is known for its light, whipped texture. It’s less dense than other brands, making it a good choice if you prefer a lighter, less intense peanut butter flavor.

Exploring the World of Jelly

Just like peanut butter, jelly comes in a wide range of flavors and textures. Some popular choices include grape, strawberry, and raspberry. But don’t be afraid to branch out and try something new, like blackberry or apricot. Some popular brands include Smucker’s, Bonne Maman, and Stonewall Kitchen.


Smucker’s is a classic choice that offers a wide range of flavors. Their jellies have a smooth, spreadable texture and a sweet, fruity flavor.

Bonne Maman

Bonne Maman is a French brand known for its high-quality, gourmet jellies. They offer a range of unique flavors, like wild blueberry and cherry.

Stonewall Kitchen

Stonewall Kitchen is an artisanal brand that offers a range of gourmet jellies. Their flavors are more complex and less sweet than other brands, making them a good choice if you’re looking for something a bit different.

Finding Your Perfect Combination

The best combination of peanut butter and jelly ultimately comes down to personal preference. You might prefer the classic combination of Jif and Smucker’s, or you might find that you prefer the gourmet combination of Peter Pan and Bonne Maman. Don’t be afraid to experiment and try different combinations until you find your perfect match.